Boat Escrow Closing Settlement Services

What you should know about boat escrow closing services.

In an industry where the value of a boat or yacht often exceeds that of a home, you would expect to find an abundance of qualified boat escrow, closing and settlement services. This is not the case, however, and for good reason. There is a great deal of mystique associated with boat titling, vessel documentation, and maritime transactions. Traditional escrow companies are therefore unwilling to swim in such waters. This guide presents an insight into what boat escrow closing settlements are all about, why there is an absence of such services and the various alternatives.

References

True Boat Escrow vs. Closing or Settlement Services

A true boat escrow is a formal legal process. It involves a neutral third party holding both the buyer’s funds and the seller’s transfer documents under written instructions. The escrow agent cannot release either until all agreed conditions are met. The agent has a fiduciary duty to both sides, and the arrangement is legally binding and enforceable under escrow law. By contrast, a closing or settlement service is more of a coordination process. The agent, which is often a broker, lender, or documentation company simply manages the paperwork, verifies title, and arranges the transfer of funds. However, they usually do not hold funds in a true escrow capacity, nor do they operate under formal escrow instructions or fiduciary obligations. In other words, a closing agent helps make the deal happen, while an escrow agent legally controls the transaction until all terms are satisfied. Most so-called “boat escrow services” are actually settlements or closings, not true escrows in the legal sense.

Why Licensed Escrow Agents Avoid Boat Transactions

Licensed escrow agents are well equipped to handle real estate, but they generally avoid boat transactions. The main reason is the complexity of marine titling and documentation laws. Unlike real estate, there is no uniform system for recording boat ownership, mortgages, or liens. Every state and the Coast Guard have their own rules, making it difficult to verify a clear title. Escrow companies also depend on title insurance to protect the parties involved. Since vessel title insurance is no longer available, licensed escrow agents have no way to insure against errors or undisclosed liens. This leaves them exposed to risks they would normally transfer to an insurer. Additionally, the specialized knowledge required to interpret Coast Guard documentation records, state registrations, and maritime liens is beyond the expertise of most escrow professionals. For that reason, most licensed escrow companies simply choose not to handle boats, preferring to limit their services to real estate and other secured property where title assurance and insurance are available.

Using an Unlicensed Closing or Settlement Service

When a closing or settlement service is not licensed or bonded, there is little protection if something goes wrong. These services often hold large deposits or purchase funds, yet there are no legal safeguards requiring them to keep client money in separate trust accounts. In some cases, funds may be mixed with their own operating accounts, creating serious risks if the company becomes insolvent or mishandles the money. Buyers and sellers also have limited recourse if an unlicensed agent fails to perform. Unlike regulated escrow companies, they are not subject to state audits, bonding requirements, or financial accountability standards. Disputes often become civil matters that are costly and time-consuming to resolve. For these reasons, anyone considering an unlicensed closing or settlement service should proceed with caution. Always confirm how the funds will be held, verify the agent’s reputation, and ensure they have experience in marine transactions before proceeding.

What to Expect From a Boat Closing Settlement Service

Boat closing and settlement services help coordinate the transfer of ownership, prepare paperwork, and distribute funds. They are useful for organizing complex transactions, especially when the buyer, seller, and lender are in different locations. However, it is important to understand what these services actually do and what they do not do. Most boat closing services act as facilitators rather than true escrow agents. They typically do not guarantee title, insure against undisclosed liens, or assume legal responsibility for the accuracy of ownership documents. Instead, they rely on the information provided by the buyer, seller, and any lienholders involved. Clients are often asked to sign waivers or disclaimers before the closing begins. These documents generally state that the service is not responsible for title defects, prior liens, or losses arising from inaccurate information supplied by the parties. While this protects the service provider, it leaves the buyer or seller with limited recourse if a problem arises after closing. In short, a closing service can be convenient, but it is not a substitute for a regulated escrow company. Buyers and sellers should read all waivers carefully, ask how funds are handled, and make sure they understand what protections are and are not included before proceeding.

Who Handles Boat Closing Settlements

Because licensed escrow agents rarely handle boat transactions, closing and settlement duties are often carried out by others within the marine industry. The most common participants include yacht brokers, marine lenders, vessel documentation agents, and occasionally attorneys. Each has a different level of expertise and responsibility.
Yacht Brokers: Consider the role of yacht brokers as boat escrow, settlement or closing agents. With few viable alternatives, they are often compelled to perform such duties themselves. Although sincere in their efforts, brokers are sales oriented and their actions may be overshadowed by a much needed commission. This sets the stage for potential conflicts with respect to management of the buyer's and seller's diverse interests. Such condition is illuminated by the fact that regulatory oversight of yacht brokerage activities is very minimal in many jurisdictions.
Marine Lenders: Marine lenders, like yacht brokers, must often act in the capacity of an escrow agent in order to close boat loan transactions. This is usually the case with small watercraft which are dealt with in the same manner as vehicles. Although financial institutions are certainly more qualified to handle escrows, they are not generally knowledgeable about boat titling issues. A borrower can however, take comfort in the fact that the lender typically has more to lose than anyone else.
Attorneys: Engaging an attorney to act as the escrow agent would seem like a logical conclusion, given the aforementioned issues. However, it is very difficult for attorneys to remain neutral while representing the diverse interests of both the buyer and seller. Many non-maritime attorneys are also unfamiliar with matters of boat titling, encumbrances, and marine liens. This is accordingly an area that is not pursued by most law firms.
Vessel Documentation Companies: There are a growing number of vessel documentation companies that now offer boat closing and settlement services. This has come about a result of increased demand from yacht brokers and marine lenders who wish to divest themselves of such responsibilities. Although most documentation agents are well versed in boat title issues, they may not be qualified to administer closings. There are no bonding or fiduciary requirements whatsoever for independent boat closing agents and very little by way of governmental oversight. Anyone using such service does so at their own risk and would be well advised to perform an exhaustive background check before entering into such an arrangement.
Online Escrow Agents: Online escrow companies have become popular in recent years, offering to hold funds and protect both parties in private transactions. While some are legitimate, others may be little more than payment processors with no true escrow authority. Their systems are usually designed for general merchandise sales, not for complex property transfers like boats. One of the main concerns is verification. Many so-called online escrow platforms operate without any state licensing, bonding, or regulatory oversight.
Buyer to Seller Direct: Many private boat sales are completed directly between buyer and seller. This avoids third-party fees but requires trust and careful handling of paperwork. The seller provides title documents, bills of sale, and lien releases when payment is made, usually by certified check or wire transfer. Direct transactions can be tricky if the parties are in different locations or a lienholder is involved. Timing is critical: the buyer wants to confirm clear title before releasing funds and the seller wants payment before releasing documents. Even in a direct exchange, involving a qualified vessel documentation or title specialist is wise. They can verify ownership, prepare proper transfer documents, and ensure all releases are recordable.

Choosing the Right Option

Selecting the right service for a boat purchase or sale depends on the value of the vessel, the location of the parties, and the level of trust between them. Because there are few true marine escrow companies, buyers and sellers must weigh the benefits and risks of each available option. If both parties are local and the transaction is straightforward, a direct exchange of payment and title documents may be sufficient. When distance or financing is involved, using a reputable marine documentation service or lender may provide added convenience. In higher-value transactions, an attorney with trust account capability can offer extra protection provided they understand vessel titling and lien requirements. No matter which option is chosen, it is critical to verify the background of anyone handling funds or title documents. Ask whether client funds are held in a separate trust account, and request written confirmation of how and when those funds will be disbursed. Always review any waivers or disclaimers before signing.

Conclusion

The information provided here was drafted my a maritime professional and further enhanced by artificial intelligence. It is subject to change without  notice and may contain errors, omissions or misstatements. You should always consult with the appropriate governmental authority or seek the assistance of a qualified attorney before acting on this material.

References
Comments - Suggestions - Corrections